A confectioner has used noisy machinery on his premises for many years. A neighbour builds a consulting room next door, then finds that the noise prevents her from working, and sues in nuisance. Which statement best describes her claim?
- It succeeds only if the noise occurs at night.
- It succeeds only if the confectioner intended to annoy her.
- It can succeed, because it is no defence that the claimant came to the nuisance.Correct answer
- It fails, because the neighbour has no right to use her land in a way that the noise affects.
- It fails, because the confectioner was there first.
Private nuisance is an unreasonable interference with the claimant's use or enjoyment of land. It is no defence that the claimant moved to or developed her land after the nuisance began.
Law basis: Sturges v Bridgman (1879) 11 Ch D 852